Upset about oil change prices?

  • Print
  • 12 Comments
  • Favorite
  • Report an error Report error
    • Thank you for your submission.
      Error report or correction
      Contact name (optional) Contact phone/e-mail (optional)  
      Sending report
    • Close

Why are some local businesses charging $42 for a full-service oil change - even though the cost of a barrel of oil is markedly down?

Is the local U.S. Post Office offering $20 per hour to new hires? And, finally, what's with corn nuts?

We look this week at these questions, posed by curious readers during the last two weeks.

Angry about oil changes

One Advocate reader was surprised by the cost of a full-service oil change during the last quarter of 2008.

A local woman complained the price jumped from $30 in April to about $42 in December - even though the cost of a barrel of oil dipped in recent months.

She faxed a copy of her December bill, which supported her beef. The oil changes were performed at Courtesy Car Wash, 7102 N. Navarro St. I called Jerry Roddy, the owner.

Roddy told me he first increased his price by $5 in August - a month in which oil and gas prices spiked - and then again by another $5 to offset yet another cost spike.

"We have to do it to stay in business. Every cost went up," he said. "We're locked into what Shell charges us for the oil."

Roddy's cost per quart increased by 51 percent last year, he said. The price he charges you, though, increased by 33 percent.

"You can see that we have not increased our prices at the rate of the increase in our cost," Roddy said.

A call to Pete's Kwik Lube, Zarbock's Automotive & Transmission and Acu-Tune show local oil-change prices vary - $18.48, $28.95 and $40 respectively.

My best advice? Shop around for prices. And remember, costs vary depending on the type of oil you buy - Castrol or Penzoil, for example - and the number of quarts your vehicle requires.

Still, shouldn't prices decrease now that a barrel of oil is cheaper?

"On Dec. 1, we received a notice from Shell that they are reducing the cost ... by 5 percent across the board," Roddy told me.

Prices at Courtesy Car Wash should drop in coming weeks.

I applaud Roddy, meanwhile, for being open and cooperative for this column. To read a formal letter he wrote about prices, visit my "Watchdog" blog, found on VictoriaAdvocate.com.

Is ad for real?

Have you read this local classified ad? "Post Office now hiring. Average pay $20 per hour or $57,000 per year. Includes federal benefits."

This ad was not placed by the U.S. Postal Service. Rather, it was placed by adSource, a marketing company for Testing Authority - a company that sells packages to "prepare you" for the post office's entrance exam.

I called the number in the ad.

"I can help you get prepared to take this exam in your area," a representative told me. "Most candidates make the mistake of not preparing for this exam."

The representative then tried to sell me a $99 exam prep package.

Ken Epley, Victoria's postmaster, said he's asked regularly about the ad.

"They are not in any way affiliated with the U.S. Post Office," Epley told me. "We're currently not hiring."

While it appears Testing Authority is not breaking any law, the Federal Trade Commission offers a toll-free number for information on service scams. Call 1-800-876-7060 before you pay for such products.

Still curious about a job with the Post Office? Search for jobs at www.USPS.com.

So, what is a corn nut?

Cleric, a regular poster on VictoriaAdvocate.com, posed this silly question: "What's with corn nuts? Are they corn or are they nuts? What's with these people?"

Well, Cleric, Albert Holloway invented corn nuts in 1936, according to Wikipedia. Corn nuts are prepared by soaking whole corn in water for three days, then deep-frying them in oil until they are hard and brittle.

I might add they are very tasty.

  • Have a question for 'Watchdog'?

    To submit questions, e-mail watchdog@vicad.com, post them to the "Watchdog" blog or call Advocate Public Service Editor Gabe Semenza at 361-580-6519. No topic is off-limits.



  • Print
  • 12 Comments
  • Favorite
  • Report an error Report error
    • Thank you for your submission.
      Error report or correction
      Contact name (optional) Contact phone/e-mail (optional)  
      Sending report
    • Close

Comments

  • The price of an oil change in a "quick" lube is expensive but you can just as easily call it a convenience lube. It's like buying a gallon of milk at a convenience store compared to going to HEB. You run into your corner convenience store and you're in and out quickly but costing more. It's the same thing with a quick lube. You're paying for the quick. And trust me those guys such as at Mr Roddy's business earn it working on hot engines. If you take your vehicle somewhere like a dealership you're going to have to wait a bit but they can be cheaper (and your vehicle will be a lot cooler when they work on it LOL). If you change your own oil it can be cheaper. On the average about $20 bucks with a name brand oil (Castrol 5 quarts average $15 and a filter $5 bucks) then you have to crawl under your car drain the oil, change the filter, add oil and check it. 10-15 minutes for average person to do only that much. Quick lube will check ALL fluids (top them off if needed), tires, filters (air filter, fuel filter etc,)Check belts, hoses, battery levels, This is just basic service. The fast lube that I managed (in another town) also vacuumed the front floor boards and washed your windshield. All of this is done in about 10 - 12 minutes. Plus they maintain shop insurance. If they damage anything on your vehicle they have insurance to cover it. If you mess it up doing it yourself you have to pay to fix it. The cost of oil is only small percentage of cost of oil change and usually the increase in oil price is not completely passed on to consumers such as in Mr Roddy's case. Thanks for being honest Mr Roddy some of us know exactly what you're dealing with.

    Don't get caught dumping used motor oil.  1 cup can get you 10 years in prison.  1 cup of used oil is all it takes to mess up water table for a long time

    January 7, 2009 at 9:50 p.m.
  • Lotex- there is no slander here, not in the story or comments. Don't make me pull my law degree. (jk) Words mean things. Ridiculous fits though. A business can charge whatever price it wants for a service such as an oil change. The market and competition will decide if that business is over charging. As has already been pointed out, no one is being forced to go to THIS business or any other for an oil change so there is no price gouging. I offer some advice. Be cautious of the lower priced oil change places. They use recycled oil and cheap-cheap filters.
    RepubWoman: Things are going to get worse. Gonna have a D in the Whitehouse, a D controlled house of reps and scary Harry Reid in all his glorious racism controlling the senate.

    January 7, 2009 at 4:56 p.m.
  • I understand how people are upset over rising prices. Is it fair? Not always. But making sure you have a running vehicle to get to work is a priority and it's funny how people are griping over rising prices to have the oil changed yet people will turn around and pay an outrageous price for that oh so important pack of cigarettes or pay every week or two to have those nails manicured. I'm sorry but in my household making sure my house, vehicle, utilities and food are paid for is my number one priority. That includes making sure my vehicle is in good running condition so I can continue to provide for my family. For those who think changing their own oil is beneath them then get a life. I guess your sh*t doesn't stink. If times continue to get hard we should all be finding ways to save money and do things for ourselves.

    January 7, 2009 at 3:56 p.m.
  • Hey MIKE, I know exactly who YOU are.

    January 7, 2009 at 3:28 p.m.
  • I'm gonna have to guess that there isn't anyone throwing rocks here, huh Frogfan. It takes all of about 10 minutes to change oil in any given vehicle, provided you own tools and can use them. All I can speak for is my comments. What I was saying (in Mr. Roddy's defense) was that if you want to B#*ch about the price for an oil change, either shop it around or do it yourself. And of course we don't throw it in the neighbers trash can, we inject it into the water table. LMAO! NO, you depose of it properly. There are companies that buy used motor oil, even decreasing your expense further on the oil change.

    January 7, 2009 at 3:27 p.m.
  • Great response by Roddy, sounds like a classy guy. What's your time worth? If you want to crawl around under a car on your day off, have at it. Otherwise have someone else do it. What do you do with the oil that comes out when you change your own oil? Put it in your neighbors fancy City of Victoria trash bin. No one will know.

    January 7, 2009 at 11:36 a.m.
  • An oil change is a service that is not based solely on the fluctuation of oil prices.

    Overhead (payroll, rent, utilities,) and location have a bearing on the SERVICE PRICE.

    Will the Watchdog use the same zeal in going after their large advertising customers?

    I imagine Mr. Roddy would love to see this subject dropped since the negative publicity does not do his business any goodÂ….. The power of the press is huge; use it wisely.

    January 7, 2009 at 9:31 a.m.
  • I agree if your gonna whine about the price, O'Reilly's has oil and oil filters for sale all day long. I'ts not that hard, just make sure that you loosen the engine oil pan drain plug and not the transmission oil pan drain plug (automatic only). I know some people are alot more proud of the services they provide, but rest assured they probably are not the only ones doing it in this town. Just be blessed that you have a car, and are able to drive it down to get the oil changed.

    January 7, 2009 at 7:14 a.m.
  • The work is under warranty, my hands don't get filthy, I don't scandalize the neighbors or the family with potty language when I drop an oil pan nut in the bucket, I don't have to haul the dirty oil to a recycling place, and I get a free car wash where I take the car. And, best of all, I get to sit and READ A BOOK while someone else does all this.

    Quitcherbellyaching or change your own oil.

    January 7, 2009 at 12:06 a.m.
  • 42 for an oil change seems steep to me, but to each his own

    January 6, 2009 at 10:54 p.m.
  • Nice to publish slander of a single moaner about a private business and what they charge. Mr. Roddy responded quite nicely.

    Try this one, Gabe. Check the $$$ per hour charge of attorneys in this county and how they justify the difference in fees. Feel brave?

    January 6, 2009 at 9:51 p.m.
  • BWAHAHAHA!! Oh man, that is too funny. Thank you for the info but you should have included the link in my question to give some background info. Click here for the video on YouTube.

    January 6, 2009 at 4:12 p.m.