The title may sound like a joke, but it’s not a laughing matter to some people in the deer-breeding business.
The Third Court of Appeals in Austin handed down a decision June 28 in an appeal filed by two deer breeders claiming that breeder deer are, or became, private property and asking to invalidate Texas Parks and Wildlife Department rules requiring breeders to test for chronic wasting disease. The Department had responded that breeder deer are wild animals and therefore “property of the people of this state.”
The court’s decision affirmed the District Court’s decision in favor of the defendants – TPWD and three of its officials.
The suit was filed just a few years ago, but this situation has been smoldering for years. CWD was first discovered in Colorado in 1967. Somewhere around 2002, Wisconsin wildlife authorities confirmed CWD had been found in deer there. Records showed Wisconsin deer had been received by Texas breeders.
CWD is fatal to deer, and there is no known remedy once it is contracted. There is also no approved live test for it, although some tests are being evaluated. It is considered to be transmitted by mouth from deer to deer. Even saliva in the soil is believed to carry it. Furthermore, CWD is a similar disease to a livestock disease that has been confirmed in Europe to affect humans.
But understand that there has not been a confirmed case of CWD in humans – not from eating venison from CWD-infected deer or kissing one on the mouth. Experts have cautioned, though, that there is no scientific proof that it can’t happen. It at least hasn’t. But CWD is serious business and could become a threat to Texas’ four million white-tailed deer and the $2.2 billion Texas deer hunting industry.
Emergency rules promulgated by the TPW Commission in 2002 prohibited further importation of deer. That closed our borders to out-of-state deer coming into Texas.
Or, it at least stopped law-abiding breeders from bringing deer into Texas. Some violated the closure rules and were discovered and prosecuted. One breeder in east Texas pleaded guilty to federal and state charges and was given three years’ probation, six months’ house arrest and $1.5 million in fines and restitution. Most of his penned deer were executed as a safety precaution. He was known to have imported many out-of-state deer, leading to both state and federal investigations.
In the recent case, the Third Court of Appeals in Austin delivered a comprehensive and well-reasoned 34-page opinion that stated, “We conclude breeder deer are public property held under a permit issued by the Department, and consequently, deer breeders do not acquire common law property rights in them.”
It also confirmed the trial court’s judgment awarding court costs and attorney’s fees of $362,967.50 against the two plaintiffs and an additional $62,895 against one individually.
The appellate court’s decision could be appealed. However, the old admonition against throwing good money after bad could be considered.