Ask Dave: Check cashing for the unbanked
By Dave Ramsey
March 15, 2014 at midnight
Updated March 14, 2014 at 10:15 p.m.
Dear Dave: I know you hate payday loan companies. Do you feel the same way about check-cashing companies? - Brian
Dear Brian: Check-cashing companies are not a good deal, but they're nowhere near as bad as payday lenders. All check-cashing businesses do is charge a fee to cash a check.
Honestly, it's kind of silly to me that places like this can make money when all you have to do is walk into a bank and open an account. But there's a percentage of our population that people in financial circles call "unbanked." This means they avoid banks for whatever reason, but in the process they leave themselves susceptible to bad deals like this.
So I don't feel the same way about check-cashing companies as I do about payday lenders. It's still not a financially smart move to pay a storefront operation a fee just to cash a check, but these businesses aren't nearly as abusive as payday lenders.
Dear Dave: My 6-year-old son has saved up $400. He said he wants to buy a motorcycle with it someday, but he recently changed his mind and wants to buy a computer tablet. Is it OK for him to change his mind like this, and how should I handle things? - Christina
Dear Christina: I'm not really concerned whether it's a motorcycle or a tablet, especially if he's saved his own money. I think the big thing we're looking for in all this is a teachable moment.
Certainly, regret is a concern, especially with a kid so young. But the reality is that neither the decision nor the possible regret afterward will ruin his life.
If you talk to him and try to advise him beforehand, and he gets upset later because he feels like he made the wrong choice, it gives you the opportunity to step in and gently say, "I'm sorry you think you made a bad choice, but that's why I wanted you to really think about it first. You had a chance to listen to Mom's wisdom and didn't. I'm sorry you feel sad now, but I want you to remember it and learn something from this bad decision."
It's a process of controlled pain and natural consequences.
One of my daughters did something similar years ago when we went to an amusement park. All the kids had a set amount of money for the day, and we warned them not to spend it too soon. She turned around and blew all her money on carnival games then spent the rest of the day whining while her brother and sister rode the rides and had lots of fun.
We didn't give her any more money, but a controlled amount of pain taught her some valuable lessons that day. She learned to listen to her mom and dad, she learned that carnival games are a rip-off, and she learned to control herself a little bit and think things through.
Allowing kids the emotional dignity of making some decisions for themselves is vitally important. You just have to make sure this liberty is supervised and comes with parental warnings and protections. It still has to be used in a way that you, as a parent, are comfortable with and deem appropriate.
There will be some natural tension in the process, but it's a great way to teach kids about money, decision making, maturity and life choices!
For financial help, visit daveramsey.com.