The meaning of a communication depends on its context. “How are you doing?” has one meaning when you greet a friend on the street and another if your friend just lost a loved one.

The cultures in which we live are vital contexts for communication. One way to define culture is a shared system of symbols. Semiotics, the study of symbols and signs, describes how these enable diverse individuals to share common meanings.

A fascinating aspect of semiotics is how signs evolve over time. The hit 1970s ballad about a man returning home from prison, “Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree,” became in 1979 a symbol for the return of American hostages held in Iran. Today, ribbons of many colors are symbols for scores of causes.

Recently, a 2018 Supreme Court ruling, Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd., v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission, turned on the symbolism of a wedding cake. The case involved a Colorado baker who, for religious reasons, refused to create a wedding cake for a gay couple. For the couple, their wedding cake symbolized acceptance and equality. For the baker, a wedding cake symbolized a divinely created order of male and female. Ultimately, the Supreme Court ruled for the baker on narrow technical grounds.

Many conservatives who cheered the Masterpiece decision fear that the Bible is being marginalized, transformed by American culture into a symbol of bigotry. They worry that believers will become socially excluded, second-class people. If you fear this scenario, then perhaps you can also imagine another.

Imagine you are a person of color in the Virginia where I grew up—where I attended Stonewall Jackson Elementary School and Washington-Lee High School, where our school colors were blue and gray, where our main thoroughfares were Lee Highway and Jefferson Davis Highway. What meaning would you take from these symbols of the majority culture? Would these meanings make you feel marginalized, socially excluded, a second-class person?

The saying goes, “It depends on whose ox is gored.” If you fear that cherished symbols are being “canceled,” pause for a moment. Yes, culture is deeply felt. Its symbols give meaning to our lives and shared contexts for our communication. When traditional symbols are questioned, we naturally react. But try to see it from someone else’s point of view. Step outside your media bubble. Talk to someone with a different perspective.

If you can’t discuss issues, if you can’t be civil, then you turn competing symbols into a zero-sum game. Once that happens, once you force only a win-lose outcome between tradition and change, there will inevitably come a time when your ox is the one that’s gored.

Two years ago, the school board in my hometown voted to rename my old high school. A group of alumni sued the board, publicly attacked its members in personal terms, and filled social media with hymns to General Lee.

In the end, the board approved the name Washington-Liberty High School. Though it will never satisfy diehards, it’s a good name, a proud name. We alumni can still wear our “W-L” memorabilia, sing our “W-L” fight song, cheer for our W-L Generals. And we can all share a symbol—liberty—that marginalizes no one, that unites rather than divides us.

Those with whom you disagree are not your enemies. The school board members who renamed my high school are people of goodwill. They strove not to “cancel,” but to preserve the best of the traditions that we all share.

The same is true of those who call on Americans to reexamine the monumental symbols of our culture.

It is also true of Victorians who ask about the symbolism of the Confederate memorial on our town plaza. Talk to them. Put yourself in their shoes. Imagine how you would feel if the symbols of culture excluded you.

Through dialogue, you can find common ground. Why? The best American traditions include us all.

Recommended For You


Mark Ward Sr. is an associate professor of communication at the University of Houston-Victoria and author of the forthcoming book “Introduction to Public Speaking: An Inductive Approach.” He may be reached at wardm@uhv.edu.

You must be logged in to react.
Click any reaction to login.
0
0
0
0
0

(4) comments

James Chandler

To me, many people are likely profiting from keeping the emotions high on racial differences. I've lived my 63 years in the south but I've never felt like the south's position in the Civil War was the humane one. Conversely, a statue like the one in Victoria to me symbolize a time when enough people realized slavery was not in agreement with God or human decency. Hundreds of thousands of people died so the terrible practice would be ended forever in this country. I tell people this and they always question me but I grew up in a home where my parents did not use racial slurs or demean others. Therefore my view has always been that this country corrected a terrible wrong but we must continue to push ourselves to be even better in treatment of our fellow human beings. Government imposing laws to force equality and politicians using race to win votes has done tremendous damage to the direction this county was going by the efforts of people like my parents. So as Americans who have been on this great journey together, I can't see how any cultural symbol cannot serve a purpose for the good even if it reflects a dark period in our history. We have to embrace and learn from our history or we are deemed to repeat it (someone said that in our history, lol). Thanks

Rick Dockery

“The first battlefield is to rewrite history… Take away the heritage of a people and they are easily persuaded.”-- Karl Marx

Interesting.

Glen or Janice Ullman

Sorry, excuse my big fat fingers. If we can’t communicate with each over our differences, and work them out, we can, at least, expect our representatives to show us how. The controversy over our local statue has died down, but still stands immutable. I crawled all over that statue as a kid, while waiting for the movies to start at the local segregated theaters, along with some my black and brown friends. It is an ambiguous statue to be fair about it. The individual is not named, and the plaque’s quote “At civilizations height immutable they stand” could be interpreted differently by some?…Glen

Glen or Janice Ullman

Bravo Mark, great points. If we can’t

Welcome to the discussion.

Transparency. Your full name is required.
Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article. And receive photos, videos of what you see.
Don’t be a troll. Don’t be a troll. Don’t post inflammatory or off-topic messages, or personal attacks.

Thank you for reading!

Please log in, or sign up for a new account and purchase a subscription to read or post comments.

To subscribe, click here. Already a subscriber? Click here.